Our Locations

55 Union Street, Suite 400
Boston, MA 02108

15 Church St, Suite 105
Salem, MA 01970

Aggressive Defense Leads to Dismissal in Decade-Old Assault and Battery Case

criminal defense attorney chelsea

The Power of Relentless Advocacy in Massachusetts: A Victory in Chelsea District Court

In the realm of criminal defense, tenacity and an aggressive pursuit of justice can mean the difference between conviction and freedom. Recently, in Chelsea District Court, I had the privilege of defending a client charged with assault and battery with a dangerous weapon, specifically a knife—a grave accusation that carried severe consequences. This case, stemming from an incident that occurred nearly a decade ago, was fraught with challenges, chiefly due to the age of the case and significant lapses in evidence management. This blog post details how an unwavering commitment to my client’s defense led to a complete dismissal of charges, underscoring my dedication as a criminal defense attorney in Massachusetts to fighting tirelessly for my clients’ rights.

The Challenge: Lost Evidence and a Decade-Old Charge

Imagine being charged with a violent felony for an incident that occurred ten years ago. For my client, this nightmare was a reality. The charges were serious: assault and battery with a dangerous weapon. The purported evidence? Video footage and photo arrays that allegedly identified my client as the perpetrator. However, when we began preparing for defense, we encountered a significant hurdle—the Chelsea Police Department had lost all the crucial files, including the video and photo evidence.

The Strategy: Aggressive Pursuit of Discovery Violations

From the outset, it was clear that the lost evidence severely compromised the prosecution’s ability to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt. Recognizing this, I embarked on an aggressive strategy to highlight the discovery violations. In criminal proceedings, the defense is entitled to access all evidence that the prosecution plans to use, as well as evidence that could exonerate the defendant. The loss of such critical evidence not only impeded a fair defense but also violated procedural justice.

Armed with this knowledge, I filed a motion to dismiss based on these significant discovery violations in Chelsea District Court. I argued that the missing evidence was crucial to the defense strategy and that its absence denied my client a fair trial. This motion emphasized the age of the case and the police department’s negligence in maintaining necessary records, which I argued was not just an oversight but a fundamental breach of legal duty.

The Hearing: Demonstrating Tenacity and Legal Acumen

During the court hearings in Chelsea, I vigorously advocated for my client’s rights. I pointed out the inconsistencies in the prosecution’s remaining evidence and underscored the importance of the lost files. My approach in the courtroom was assertive—challenging every point made by the prosecution and insisting on the highest standard of proof.

The hearing was a testament to the importance of a defense attorney who is willing to relentlessly fight for their clients. It became evident that the prosecution’s case was irreparably weakened by their inability to produce the primary evidence they had relied upon for the charges.

The Outcome: Charges Dismissed

After several rounds of hearings and rigorous scrutiny of the facts, the judge in Chelsea District Court granted our motion to dismiss. The decision was based not only on the lost evidence but also on the unreasonable delay in prosecution, which I argued had prejudiced my client’s ability to mount a fair defense.

This outcome was a significant victory for my client, who had lived under the cloud of these serious charges for a decade. It also reaffirmed my commitment to aggressively defending my clients, no matter how daunting the odds.

Why an Aggressive Criminal Defense Attorney Matters

This case highlights why choosing an aggressive criminal defense attorney in Massachusetts, particularly for cases tried in Chelsea District Court, is critical. The stakes in criminal defense are incredibly high, and the quality of defense can significantly impact the outcome. As your attorney, I am dedicated to ensuring that every legal avenue is pursued, every piece of evidence is scrutinized, and every procedural error is challenged.

Conclusion: Your Defense is Only as Strong as Your Defender

In conclusion, the dismissal of these decade-old charges against my client not only underscores the importance of maintaining a robust defense but also illustrates the pivotal role of an aggressive attorney who is committed to justice and the rights of the accused. If you or someone you know is facing criminal charges, remember that the defense you choose can make all the difference. Choose wisely—choose a defender who will fight tirelessly for you.

For more information on how to defend against criminal charges or to discuss your case, please feel free to contact me. As a seasoned criminal defense attorney in Massachusetts, I am here to help you navigate the complexities of the legal system with confidence and aggressive advocacy.  You can text or call me at 617-295-7500.  Put me to work on your criminal defense!


Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney.  Please do not rely on anything on this page as legal advice because any specific advice would depend on your situation.  Any results posted on this page are not guarantees of outcomes in your case.

Boston Attorney

The court system is stressful, whether you’re being charged with a crime, being sued, suing someone, or fighting for your ability to stay and work in this country. You need someone who appreciates this and can dedicate the time not only to represent you effectively in court but to guide you through the process.

Recent Articles

Contact us