Matthew Peterson Secures NOT GUILTY Verdict for MBTA Driver Charged with Negligence

Written By: Matthew W. Peterson

Published: 01/11/2023

Share Us:

Successful Defense Against Gross Negligence Charges: A Case Study

On January 11, 2023, a significant legal victory unfolded in the Boston Municipal Court, Brighton, when a jury delivered a NOT GUILTY verdict for our client, who faced serious charges related to an incident involving the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA). This case highlights the importance of skilled legal representation and the nuances of Massachusetts law as it pertains to criminal defense.

Background of the Case

The incident in question occurred on July 30, 2021, when our client was operating a green line trolley on the B branch near Boston University. During this time, his train collided with another green line trolley on the same track. Initially charged with felony gross negligence as a common carrier, the stakes were high. However, thanks to diligent legal work, we successfully filed a motion to dismiss the felony charge, reducing the case to a misdemeanor.

Legal Framework in Massachusetts

In Massachusetts, common carriers are held to a higher standard of care due to their responsibility for transporting passengers safely. Under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 160, Section 1, common carriers must exercise utmost care and diligence in their operations. However, proving gross negligence requires more than just establishing that an accident occurred; it necessitates demonstrating a severe departure from the standard of care expected in such situations.

Building a Strong Defense

Our defense strategy centered around establishing that the incident was an unfortunate accident rather than an act of gross negligence. Key elements of our approach included:

Evidence of Unconsciousness: Our client initially reported to law enforcement that he had no recollection of the events leading up to the collision. This statement was crucial in demonstrating that he was not operating the train recklessly or with disregard for safety.
Witness Testimony: We called upon a passenger from the train who testified that our client appeared unresponsive following the crash. This testimony supported our argument that he was not in control of his faculties at the time of the incident.
Accident Analysis: Expert analysis was employed to review the circumstances surrounding the collision. The evidence suggested that various factors contributed to the accident, none of which indicated gross negligence on our client’s part.

The Trial and Verdict

The trial garnered significant media attention, with news cameras capturing every moment from opening statements to closing arguments. This public scrutiny underscored the importance of presenting a compelling narrative that resonated with jurors.

Ultimately, after careful deliberation, the jury concluded that “sometimes an accident is just an accident.” Their verdict reflected an understanding that not all unfortunate incidents stem from negligence or malfeasance. Our client’s acquittal was not just a personal victory; it reinforced the principle that accidents can occur without culpability.

The Importance of Experienced Legal Representation

This case serves as a reminder of why securing experienced legal counsel is vital when facing criminal charges. At the Law Office of Matthew Peterson, we understand the complexities of Massachusetts law and are dedicated to providing personalized legal strategies tailored to each client’s unique situation.

If you or someone you know is facing criminal charges in Boston or its surrounding areas, it’s crucial to act quickly and seek professional guidance. The consequences of a conviction can be severe and long-lasting.

Contact Us for Your Legal Defense Needs

If you find yourself in need of a criminal defense attorney who understands both the intricacies of Massachusetts law and how to navigate complex cases effectively, look no further than the Law Office of Matthew Peterson. We are committed to fighting for your rights and ensuring you receive fair treatment under the law.

Call or text us today at 617-295-7500 to discuss your case and begin crafting your defense strategy. Your future deserves dedicated advocacy and expert guidance—let us be your trusted partner in achieving justice.

Related Victory Cases:

Law Office of Matthew W. Peterson Gets NOT GUILTY Verdict for Client Charged with Domestic Violence

Law Office of Matthew W. Peterson Secures Probation for Client Facing Life Without Parole

Law Office of Matthew Peterson Gets DISMISSAL of Domestic Violence Charges

Law Office of Matthew W. Peterson Gets NOT GUILTY Verdict in OUI Case

Law Office of Matthew W. Peterson Secures DISMISSAL of Drug, Child Endangerment Charges

Law Office of Matthew Peterson Secures DISMISSAL in Possession of Cocaine Case

Law Office of Matthew W. Peterson Gets Domestic Violence Case DISMISSED After Pretrial Diversion

Law Office of Matthew W. Peterson Secures DISMISSAL of Larceny Charges

Law Office of Matthew Peterson Secures NOT GUILTY in Obstruction Case

Law Office of Matthew W. Peterson Gets NOT GUILTY in Multiple Attempted Murder Cases

Law Office of Matthew W. Peterson Secures NOT GUILTY in Shoplifting Charge