Sealed Indictments in Massachusetts: A Plain-English Guide

Published: 12/10/2025

Share Us:

Facing a criminal charge can be confusing, especially when terms like sealed indictment come up. This guide explains what a sealed indictment is in Massachusetts and answers common questions in simple terms. We’ll cover what sealed indictments are, why they’re used, how they affect arrests, when they become public, and what to do if you learn you’ve been indicted under seal.

What Is a Sealed Indictment?

In Massachusetts, serious criminal charges are often brought by indictment, which is a formal accusation issued by a grand jury. Normally, an indictment becomes part of the public court record once it’s returned. However, a sealed indictment is different. It means the indictment is kept confidential, not available to the public or even to the defendant, until a later stage (usually until the defendant is arrested and brought to court). In other words, the charges exist but are filed under seal so no one can disclose them prematurely.

Massachusetts Rule of Criminal Procedure 5(d) explicitly allows a judge to direct that an indictment be “kept secret until after arrest,” with the court clerk sealing it and prohibiting any disclosure of the indictment’s existence except as necessary to execute an arrest warrant.

This procedure has been upheld by Massachusetts courts (for example, the state’s Supreme Judicial Court noted that sealed indictments conceal all information from the defendant until the arrest warrant is carried out). Essentially, a sealed indictment in Massachusetts is a set of charges that remain hidden until law enforcement is ready to act on them.

Why Are Some Indictments Sealed?

There are a few important reasons why prosecutors and courts might choose to seal an indictment instead of making it immediately public. Sealing an indictment is meant to serve and protect the justice process. Common reasons include:

Preventing Flight or Evidence Destruction: Keeping the indictment secret ensures the suspect doesn’t find out about the charges and flee the jurisdiction or destroy evidence before police can make an arrest. If a person knows they’ve been indicted, they might try to run or hide evidence/assets. Sealing avoids tipping someone off.
Protecting Ongoing Investigations: In complex cases (for example, involving multiple suspects or an undercover operation), disclosing the indictment could jeopardize an ongoing investigation. A sealed indictment allows law enforcement to continue gathering evidence or coordinating arrests without alerting other potential suspects.
Ensuring Safety of Witnesses and Officers: By keeping the charges confidential until the defendant is in custody, authorities can help ensure that witnesses, informants, or police officers are not exposed to retaliation or harm. Secrecy minimizes the risk that the accused might take desperate actions if they learn of the indictment before being arrested.

In short, sealed indictments are used when making the charges public right away could interfere with the case or public safety.

Arrest After a Sealed Indictment in Massachusetts

Can I be arrested after a sealed indictment in MA? Yes. In fact, that’s exactly the point of a sealed indictment. If you have been indicted under seal, you can and likely will be arrested, even if you weren’t arrested at the time the grand jury issued the indictment.

Typically, when a grand jury returns a sealed indictment, an arrest warrant or a summons is also issued. When the indictment is sealed, law enforcement can execute the indictment warrant at a strategic time. The indictment remains hidden so that the arrest can happen by surprise, if necessary.

What happens if I was indicted but not arrested right away? In Massachusetts, it’s possible to be indicted but not arrested immediately. If a sealed indictment was returned against you and you haven’t been arrested yet, it usually means the case has officially begun (the charges have been filed), but the authorities have not yet taken you into custody.

This delay could happen for various reasons. For example, police might be still locating you, or they might be waiting to arrest multiple people at once in a larger investigation. It’s important to know that the indictment isn’t “inactive” or forgotten during this time, it’s simply sealed. You won’t typically be notified of the indictment until you are arrested or summoned to court, because the court is keeping it secret per the judge’s order.

The sealed indictment still has legal effect, and the case is essentially pending in the background. Once you are arrested (or you turn yourself in), the indictment will be unsealed and you will go before a judge for an arraignment on those charges.

Bottom line: Being indicted (even secretly) means there is a formal charge against you. If you somehow learned of a sealed indictment naming you as the individual charged, you should be aware that your arrest may be imminent.

When Do Sealed Indictments Become Public?

Because a sealed indictment is initially kept off the public record, you may wonder when (and if) it will eventually become public. In Massachusetts, sealed indictments become public once they are unsealed, which almost always happens after the defendant is arrested and brought to court. Mass. R. Crim. P. 5(d) indicates the indictment stays secret “until after arrest.”

In practical terms, this means that at the moment of arrest (or by the time of first court appearance, such as an arraignment), the indictment is revealed. The charges will then be entered into the public court docket, and the case will proceed like any other criminal case. At that point, anyone can obtain the indictment from the court records, and media can report on it.

In other words, indictments are public record in Massachusetts once they are unsealed. A standard (unsealed) indictment is filed with the court clerk and available for public inspection as soon as it’s returned by the grand jury and processed by the court.

However, a sealed indictment remains a private record until the court lifts the seal. When the indictment is unsealed (usually shortly after arrest), it becomes part of the public record. The reasoning behind this timing is straightforward: keeping it sealed up to the arrest protects the investigation, but after the arrest, there is usually less need for secrecy.

At that point, you have the right to know the charges, and the public has an interest as well. In rare cases, a court might choose to unseal an indictment earlier (for example, if a prosecutor requests it or a judge finds a compelling public interest), but such situations are uncommon. Generally, the seal is lifted as soon as the suspect is in custody and the legal proceedings begin.

What Should I Do If I Find Out About a Sealed Indictment?

Discovering that you’ve been secretly indicted can be unsettling, but it’s important to stay calm and take responsible steps. Here’s what you should consider doing:

Consult an Experienced Attorney: If you get word (or even just a strong hint) that you have a sealed indictment against you, contact a Massachusetts criminal defense lawyer immediately. An attorney can often confirm if an indictment exists and advise you on the next steps. They will also start preparing your defense and be ready to represent you once the indictment is unsealed.
Don’t Panic or Do Anything Rash: It’s natural to feel anxious, but try to remain calm. Do not attempt to flee or go into hiding, that could make your situation worse where running from charges can be viewed as consciousness of guilt. Likewise, don’t confront witnesses or investigators, and avoid discussing the situation with anyone other than your lawyer. Such conduct could lead to new charges. Remember that a sealed indictment means things are still confidential by court order; keep it that way and let your Massachusetts defense attorney handle communications.
Prepare for the Arrest or Surrender: In many cases, if you know an indictment is looming, you might arrange with your lawyer to voluntarily surrender to authorities. Turning yourself in can sometimes lead to a smoother process: you avoid the surprise of a public arrest at home or work, and it shows the court you’re cooperating. This gives your lawyer a strong argument at your bail hearing. Your attorney may be able to coordinate the timing and conditions of arrest (for example, ensuring you can be quickly brought before a judge for a bail hearing). Even if you don’t surrender voluntarily, mentally and practically prepare for the possibility of an arrest. This could include having a plan for childcare, work obligations, or securing funds for bail.
Know Your Rights at Arraignment: Once you are arrested on a sealed indictment, you will go to court for an arraignment, where the charges will be formally read and you’ll enter a plea. At this point, the indictment is no longer sealed. Make sure you have legal representation at this hearing. Your lawyer can argue for reasonable bail and begin the process of obtaining discovery (the evidence against you). Keep in mind that an indictment is not a conviction – you will have the opportunity to defend yourself in court.

Key takeaway: If you find out about a sealed indictment against you, take a deep breath and get legal help. Being proactive and responsible can make a big difference in the outcome. The situation may feel intimidating, but understanding the process will help you navigate it.

Sealed indictments are a procedural step to facilitate arrests and protect cases – once you’re in the system, the normal rules of justice (like the presumption of innocence and the right to a fair trial) still apply to you.

Conclusion

Sealed indictments in Massachusetts are essentially indictments that remain hidden from public view (and from the accused) until an arrest is made. They are used to avoid tipping off suspects and creating circumstances for a risky arrest. If you or someone you know is facing a sealed indictment, remember that this is a standard legal procedure (authorized by Massachusetts law), and you will have the chance to address the charges once they are unsealed.

By staying calm, informing yourself, and working with a qualified attorney, you can respond to a sealed indictment in a way that protects your rights and sets you up for the best possible outcome under the circumstances.

Although I am an attorney, I am not your attorney. Please do not rely on anything on this page as legal advice because any specific advice would depend on your situation. Any results posted on this page are not guarantees of outcomes in your case.